Saturday, 30 November 2013

REVIEW: Oldboy

By Chris Luckett

1½ stars out of 5

Photo: Universal Pictures
When the Korean revenge movie Oldboy was released in 2003, it became a buzzed-about cult hit largely because of three things: its cringe-inducing violence, its stylized action, and its jaw-dropping climax. Spike Lee’s English remake has no style and it fumbles its ending, leaving a grotesque mess.

Oldboy’s premise is that Joe (Josh Brolin) – a degenerate businessman who hits on his clients’ wives, drinks every chance he gets, and doesn’t visit his 3-year-old daughter – is kidnapped one 1993 night and awakens in what looks at first like a motel room but is actually a personal prison. The room’s window is fake and the only door is bolted shut.

After resignedly giving up hope of escaping, Joe turns to his only window to the outside world, the in-room TV. He discovers on the news that his ex-wife has been murdered, his daughter has been adopted, and he has been named the killer (thanks to planted DNA).

Photo: Universal Pictures
For 20 years, Joe consumes the dumplings and vodka he’s given daily, he writes and stockpiles desperate letters to his daughter, and he watches the world go by through his television. Then one day, without warning, he’s released. With no understanding of what he did to deserve his punishment and 20 years of seething fury, Joe goes on a mission of revenge.

The concept is preposterous and hinges on the ending giving an answer of such scale that it overcomes that. The original, despite its occasional missteps, stuck its landing with a jaw-dropping turn of the plot in its climax; the 2013 version trips and stumbles with it, in part due to Sharlto Copley playing his villainous role as if he has a maniacal moustache to twirl.

Photo: Universal Pictures
Park Chan-Wook’s version had a visual flair that amped up the gore for key moments but shied away from it for others. Lee’s version goes for an all-is-more approach, showing everything from severed tongues to lumps of flesh. Without any style, it starts off nauseating and fast becomes numbing.

As its own movie, the new Oldboy is unlikeable, gruesome and dull. As a remake, it forgets that Joe’s revenge, deep down, is less about exacting vengeance than about trying to understand his imprisonment. By the time Spike Lee’s Oldboy gets to its answers, nobody really cares what the question was.

VIDEO REVIEW: Catching Fire

VIDEO REVIEW: All is Lost

VIDEO REVIEW: Dallas Buyers Club

VIDEO REVIEW: Blue is the Warmest Colour

Saturday, 23 November 2013

REVIEW: Catching Fire

By Chris Luckett

4 stars out of 5

Photo: Lionsgate
Twenty or 30 years ago, film adaptations usually didn’t have to worry about aping their source books exactly. The recent influx of book series with rabid fan bases being adapted into films, though, has led to filmmakers being afraid to cut scenes that worked in the book but don’t in the movie. Catching Fire is a better movie than The Hunger Games was, but it still ultimately falls into the same traps by treating its source novel as gospel.

A year after the events of The Hunger Games, victors Katniss (Jennifer Lawrence) and Peeta (Josh Hutcherson) have returned to their lives in District 12, but are continually haunted by nightmares and PTSD flashbacks. Katniss’s defiance of the rules in the prior Hunger Games has led to sparks of rebellion amongst the volatile, oppressed districts of Panem.

Photo: Lionsgate
President Snow (Donald Sutherland) wants to quell any insurrection before it starts, for which he blames Katniss. Along with the new gamemaker, Plutarch Heavensbee (Philip Seymour Hoffman), Snow creates a Survivor: All-Stars edition of the Hunger Games, allowing for the re-reaping of Katniss and Peeta.

Catching Fire tells a somewhat similar story as the first movie while crafting more complex characters and darker tones than the original had time for. What could have felt reheated instead feels amped up in scale and stakes. It doesn’t hurt that this had twice the budget of The Hunger Games, either, as the visual effects are much better this time around. All the returning actors are excellent, particularly Lawrence and Sutherland, and new additions to the cast like Hoffman, Jena Malone, and Jeffrey Wright fit right in.

Photo: Lionsgate
If there’s a flaw with the movie, it’s being too slavish to the pacing of the book. The first half of Catching Fire is all character development and set-up, which worked much better in literary form than it does here. By the time the Games actually begin, more than half the movie’s running time has elapsed, which barely worked in the first movie and here just feels uneven.

The final book of Suzanne Collins’ trilogy, Mockingjay, is being split into two movies, like the Harry Potter and Twilight climaxes. Carrying the momentum of Catching Fire forward will be the filmmakers’ biggest challenge, as this one does pretty much everything right and does it better than the first one. And just maybe, by stretching its story over two movies, Mockingjay will be forced to accept being different from its book.

REVIEW: All is Lost

By Chris Luckett

5 stars out of 5

All is Lost is about a man alone at sea whose sailboat springs a leak when it hits an adrift cargo container. Through a series of misfortunes, his situation slowly gets worse, despite his every knowledgeable efforts. His tenacious battle to survive as every element turns against him is the crux of this marvellously thrilling movie.

Photo: Lionsgate
It’s hard to imagine how All is Lost got made. The entire movie takes place at sea, either aboard a sailboat or in a life raft. Only one actor is seen during the entire movie. At 77, that one actor (Robert Redford) is seemingly too old to appeal to younger demographics or to even meet the physical demands required for the movie. It’s only the second movie written and directed by J.C. Chandor. Oh, and outside of 15 seconds of pre-credits voiceover, only two words are spoken during the entire 106 minutes of All is Lost (one of which isn’t suitable for print).

And yet...

Photo: Lionsgate
All is Lost is an absolutely riveting movie. Much like Ben Affleck’s improvement between Gone Baby Gone and The Town, J.C. Chandor has gone from a great debut to a sophomore masterpiece. His writing is so spare that it’s a shock the few times we actually hear Redford’s voice, yet the action is methodically well-written. The movie is also very effectively shot. There are parts of it that are like Life of Pi, Cast/Away, The Perfect Storm, and Open Water, but All is Lost does each familiar scenario better than its progenitors.

Photo: Lionsgate
Robert Redford wholly inhabits the nameless protagonist and masterfully emotes decades of experiences and relationships without saying a word. (Just the way he gives himself time to momentarily relax after almost dying before doggedly getting right back up, or the way he slightly rolls his eyes at each cruel twist of fate, says more than pages of dialogue could.) And the ocean in All is Lost is a character itself, with its own temper, generosity, and mercuriality.

It’s fitting that 2013 gave the world both Gravity and All is Lost, as they’re almost companion pieces. Like Gravity, All is Lost paints a gripping tale of one person relentlessly struggling to survive against harsh elements and cruel odds. Also, like Gravity, All is Lost is one of the very best movies of the year.